Burr begins his book by demonstrating the mysterious nature of smell. The reader will be surprised that something that seems so mundane could actually be so fascinating. For those attracted to science, this section of the book is very interesting. How, for instance, can a person define the smell of certain molecules that they have never encountered before? Burr brakes down difficult scientific concepts such as spectroscopy and cell-protein recognition as he describes theories on how humans smell. As Burr explores the mystery of smell with Turin as his guide, he also looks at the process of developing and publishing a scientific theory. The book focuses on Turin’s theory that we smell as the result of the vibrations from the electrons of atoms that signal cells in our noses. As he describes Turin’s struggle to publish and expand his theory, Burr exposes the darker side of science, such as the back-stabbing nature of peer review and the conflicts that occur when science mixes with corporations. These conflicts add intrigue to the story and combine with the mystery of smell to make the book an interesting read.

This book draws its readers in and makes them want to learn more about the chemistry of smell. Due to Burr’s casual writing style, this book would not be recommended as a Cornerstone book. However, Burr’s combination of Turin’s struggles with the fascinating science of smell generates an intriguing and recommended novel.

~ Griffin G. of Cumberland, ME
1st Place 12th Grade / Read, Write &Win 2007