Book
Review
No essay in the
last century has created more discussion and controversy than C.P.
Snow's Two Cultures. The title itself has become part of
every college graduate's vocabulary along with Thomas Kuhn's "paradigm
shift" and a few other trendy metaphors now quoted in the media.
Yet Snow's title seems to dominate the metaphorical landscape.
C.P. Snow published his 1959 Rede lecture under the title The Two
Cultures and the Scientific Revolution. His four brief chapters
of 54 pages define the thesis about the two cultures - the literary
and the scientific. The other sections on The Intellectuals as Natural
Luddites, The Scientific Revolution, and the Rich and the Poor support
his main contention. Perhaps his last section is the weakest and
least interesting to the reader but certainly not without merit.
The heart of the essay deals with his criticism of the modern writers,
the intellectuals who make no attempt to understand the Second Law
of Thermodynamics or any part of the scientific culture. These writers,
the so-called intellectuals, are natural Luddites, and their political
views brought "Auschwitz that much nearer."
The way out of the cultural divide, Snow asserts, is a rethinking
of our education. The remaining chapters deal with a survey of professional
training in the leading countries of the world like England, Germany,
Russia, and the U.S. The final chapter focuses on how the rich countries
can help the poor to establish a higher standard of living.
Over the 40 years since its appearance, Snow's essay has generated
responses from the leading critics and scientists in each decade.
The bibliography on the Internet alone would keep one busy for a
college semester. This landmark essay is still worth reading after
all these years.
~ John Smith, Former Department Head, English, Brunswick High School
|